There are only two ways to pay for Obama’s Health Care Reform: reduce benefits and (or) increase taxes. Reducing benefits is hard. Look what happened when government bureaucrats tried to ration mammograms for women under 50. People stood up in revolt. Everybody knows what breast cancer is.
It is much easier for the government to tax. The reason is: most Americans do not do their own taxes. Even those who do it themselves don’t understand it. The shining example is the Treasury Secretary Timothy Geitner, who didn’t understand the Turbo Tax instructions. We just feed the info from our W2 forms and from our receipts into a computer program and let the thing do the thinking for us.
In this post I’ll try to explain to you the taxes that are coming at us with the Obama’s Health Care Reform – so you can spot them and recognize them for what they are.
Let’s start with: What is “Tax” for Dummies: Money that comes out of your pocket and goes to IRS account is a tax. The Obama administration prefers to call them “revenue enhancements”. May be because it sounds kind of French they think that “revenue enhancement” term will divert attention from what they are doing.
Just remember the rule for recognizing tax: from your pocket to IRS account.
Now let us look at proposed taxes in the Heath Care Bill in “around the kitchen table” terms.
1. They call it “Employer Sponsored Insurance Tax Exclusion”. Here is the point where you give up and pay Tax-Services to do your taxes. Let me try to explain.
At the moment money that are taken from your paycheck for health insurance are tax-free. The money you pay for health insurance is often not even included in your W2 form taxable income. If the government taxes those health insurance payments you may not even notice. Your taxable income on your W2 form will look bigger and you may think you made more money, when in fact that money were never in your pocket - they went to the health insurance companies and you will be stuck with paying taxes on them.
Who came up with the idea of such tax? No, not Obama. John McCain proposed it during the ’08 campaign. People hated it and McCain lost the election. Now Obama’s people are trying to sneak it into the bill as “republican’s approved”. Really?
2. “Sin Taxes”. Extra taxes on cigarettes, alcohol and sugary drinks. People understand this one. One of the first tax increases Obama imposed was the cigarette tax that was supposed to pay for children health care. This one is working just fine for the President as the number of smokers in America is increasing for the first time in a decade. May be Obama administration thought that all smokers in America make more than 250 K a year and taxed them, because the Candidate Obama promised no taxes for the people making less than 250K a year.
3. “Changes to the Payroll tax”. You have no clue what it is, but you think – this must be good, after all we voted for Change. Are you sure? Such a change will mean to you increase of the amount you already pay for Medicare. But instead of fixing fraud in Medicare, Democrats are wondering if you are willing to pay more taxes first. In the 2000+ pages of the health care bill there is nothing that makes it clear how the Government will get rid of the fraud and mismanagement in Medicare. A future commission will tell you details about it later.
4. “Coverage mandate”. This one is my favorite. We gave the Democrats Mandate and they give it back to us. There is a special social feeling when Government makes something mandatory – don’t you feel that we belong together? Obama’s health care bill will penalize everybody who has no insurance and is over 150% poverty line. Bunch of healthy young people fit in this category. Their only HOPE to escape the penalty tax may be the US Supreme Court if somebody dares to challenge this tax as unconstitutional. President Obama said this is not a tax – this is a penalty. This penalty comes out of your pocket and is collected with your tax-return form – goes to the IRS account. I call it a tax. It is up to you to decide.
Democrats say that those who lack insurance cost the rest of us and it is time for them to pick up their own tab. Well, those who are able but out of work cost us money too. Is the Government going to make “having a job” mandatory? They may fix unemployment the same way they intend to fix the health insurance. Just make it mandatory. Obama may also make peace mandatory so he can actually earn his Nobel Peace Prize.
5. Eliminating Health Care Tax Benefits means less chance to deduct health care costs from your taxable income.
6. Value Added Tax means taxing every bolt and nut on those wheel chairs and scooters and walkers, oxygen tanks, everything that assist the life of the people. Yes, tax the sick people.
You can see through the taxes. It takes a little effort, but it is not impossible. Or you can just ignore it all, because you may as well discover next what the Earned Income Credit means. That will really blow your mind.









November 24th, 2009 at 5:36 am
Thanks for pointing all of that out Ellie. It looks like our free health care won’t be so free after all.
There will also be huge state tax hikes connected to these bills.
Dick Morris and Eileen McGann: Obamacare: Big State Tax Hikes
http://townhall.com/columnists/DickMorrisandEileenMcGann/2009/11/23/obamacare_big_state_tax_hikes
November 24th, 2009 at 6:07 am
Nice link, Fly. Dick Morris also does wonderful job in explaining the health benefits cut and rationing care.
November 24th, 2009 at 7:02 am
The Democrats don’t care at all about what happens to the American people as long as they get their Health care bill passed for the so called President that cares about America. How many more jobs will this cost us and who will pay for this bill. WE WILL PAY FOR THIS BILL
November 24th, 2009 at 7:04 am
The Democrats don’t care about the cost or who will pay for their bill just as long as it passes to make our so called President who really cares about the American people and make sure it passes. He is going to be one of the worst Presidents in US history as well he should be. Let’s go in debt some more and who will pay for all of this. WE WILL AND i HOPE ALL THE DEMOCRATS GET VOTED OUT OF OFFICE BECAUSE YOU DESERVE IT.
November 24th, 2009 at 9:01 am
the reform will be paid by insurers,pharaceutical companies and the collapse of acute care hospitals..the way health care will be delivered will radically reduce costs by eliminating hospitals. They will adapt and become primary care centers,wellness centers,free standing ASU or attached to medical homes or they will close or merge.
November 24th, 2009 at 9:13 am
The “reform” is going to be paid for by the middle class, just like every other entitlement program we have. The fact is that this legislation does nothing to address actually reducing health-care costs. In fact quite the opposite. Numerous studies have already come out evaluating this legislation and agree that costs in terms of premiums and real medical costs will go up not down. I’m all for health-reform, but this isn’t reform, it’s a colossal waste of money that will not accomplish what it purports to.
November 24th, 2009 at 9:15 am
Excellent post Ellie. I have a few “suggestions” for you.
1. Never look down upon your audience. Some may consider sentences such as this-( “most Americans do not do their own taxes. Even those who do it themselves don’t understand it.”) to be slightly condesending
Instead look for ways to improve your self.
In your post I noticed many grammatical errors.
But overall the post was great and it does explains the txaes in laymans terms.
November 24th, 2009 at 9:29 am
Tim, thank you for your suggestions. Since English is my second foreign language I am learning all the time. As for looking down on fellow Americans - I apologize if it came out this way - what I mean is most of us use programs like Turbo Tax or on-line products or tax-preparation services. We put the data inside and the programs give us the result. What is the thinking behind the tax code is hard to tell, because it is very complicated.
November 24th, 2009 at 1:52 pm
Ellie,
Since English is your 2nd language then I would say you are doing terrific . What is your 1st language ?
November 24th, 2009 at 1:54 pm
If you want me to show you some of the grammatical errors, just shoot me an email. If not, do nothing. I do enjoy your posts very much.
November 24th, 2009 at 2:58 pm
My native language is Bulgarian. My first foreign is Russian, I finished high school in the USSR /long time ago apparently/ where my parents used to work. I am naturalized American citizen since 2006.
November 24th, 2009 at 3:15 pm
tim v,
did you mean “condescending”?
November 24th, 2009 at 4:50 pm
I’ll put it in the simplest terms possible. We pay more taxes.
November 24th, 2009 at 6:43 pm
Hey cool, this post got a link from National Review.
November 24th, 2009 at 6:44 pm
http://www.nationalreview.com/topics/healthcare/
November 24th, 2009 at 7:49 pm
The thing that really get on my nerves are the people. They want free healthcare, but they say the rich should pay for it. So why not the rich pay for your food,cars,healthcare,education,movies,self phones, and homes, because they never worked for that money and deserve to keep it.
November 24th, 2009 at 8:06 pm
Can someone please tell me why the rich who don’t really even use as many government departments as the poor should have to pay more taxes just, because they work harder?
November 24th, 2009 at 10:06 pm
the sad part is that the dems and obama keep saying that
“they” will pay more taxes
the money for obamacare will come from “them”
but who are these “others”?
who are these “residue creatures” who will be paying for “us”?
they are our neighbors. the people who build our houses. the people who make our cars. the people who collect our pap smears … and do our taxes. the people give us that extra bit of whip cream on our hot cocoa.
they are our parents, our friends, and our children.
“they” are “us”