For those of you that follow the earlier Star Trek series and the Vulcan Spock, will recognize “Amok Time” as the insane period of passion where the non-emotional and analytical Vulcan species are driven do anything to mate with their betrothed. Spock even went to the brink of getting in a fight-to-the-death wtih his beloved Captain during Amok Time. (Wikipedia post here.)
That being said, we are all left with an unfathomable lingering fog as to what would drive a married Naval Academy graduate test pilot astronaut to travel 900+ miles in diapers to accost a perceived competitor in a perceived love triangle that probably never existed to begin with?
Granted, just because someone is smart, driven and successful, even among our finest military, political or business leaders, does not mean the person knows a whit about affairs of the heart. As the tawdry tapes of Prince Charles and Carmela speaking to each other in nauseating terms can attest, people can be reduced to blathering idiots when their thoughts turn to love (or infatuation).
In the most recent public expression of love by a well-rounded and successful Space Shuttle Astronaut tells us, reason can be thrown out the window along with wigs and other things, when emotion shuts down the thinking part of our brains.
Ms. Nowak had 3 kids, two of them twin 5 year olds, a job which commands large amounts of time and continuous study, lots of TDY time to Florida and PR stints throughout the country and the very real down-to-earth responsibilities of homework, laundry, crying 5 year olds, a (probably) dating 15 year old high school son, AND to be a doting wife to a husband of 19 years. Her life was teatering on the edge for years and career women of all stripes can attest to the strain that a normal career can have on a person, let alone someone with the high profile job of an astronaut.
NASA is not known for its great management and as many professionals can attest, going to one’s superior and telling them you need a mental health break is not usually condusive to one’s career. Apparently, there were clues to problems previous to Ms. Nowak’s tragic actions. I suspect that she did not have the option of going to her superiors and telling them she needed a break. Sure, we are told, the astronaut corps is a tight-knit family group that takes care of their own. People I know that work in Houston confirm that. However, it is also traditionally, a corps of military test pilots and former military officers to whom “macho” is considered essential - even among the women. Sure, she would have been offered leave, but she would never again fly aboard a Space Shuttle or served at the communications console at Houston Control. I suspect that Lisa Nowak had no relief valve and neither do any of the other astronauts or professionals at NASA.
Universities and many religious denominations recognize the strain that highly driven professionals are under for extended periods of time and many REQUIRE a sabbatical of at least 3 months to be taken periodically (the Methodist church, I can attest to, requires sabbatical leaves of at least 3-6 months every 7 years of its pastors). This requirement relieves people from the responsibility and stigma of asking for a much-needed rest. Perhaps NASA needs to do the same.
I am deeply saddened by the image of Lisa Nowak - a career shattered, one of America’s finest having her innermost thoughts played out in the international press, and all that NASA training wasted. A further problem is the deepening tarnish of the image of NASA and the discouragement of those of us who dream for wider space travel by the very real spectacle of lowered funding in the midst of the disgrace of this once great American agency icon.
I am also saddened personally, as space travel for women was not available for me as a young girl to dream about, as only men were selected as astronauts, so it hurts even more to see a woman who did get to live my dream be so utterly shattered. It is also, unfortunately, indicative of our society as a whole. How many lives are shattered because people just don’t feel they have a way out? Mental illness and mental incapacity due to stress is still viewed as shameful in our society.
Perhaps NASA can pave the way on earth, as they have done in space, and begin requiring mental health breaks (sabbaticals) for those folks in whom our nation has place such a great stake. Just a thought.
***Update***
Fox News online has an article about the stress on female astronauts - remember, you read it here first… “Observers: Astronaut Lisa Nowak Suffered ‘Mental Anguish’ Over Career, Love Life”











February 8th, 2007 at 9:13 am
This is indeed a tragedy. I hope and pray Ms. Nowak can pull her life together. Reminds me of another science fiction story, “Forbidden Planet”, where a super-advanced society was destroyed by their own “monsters from the Id”. Even the best, brightest and most respected among us share the same dark urges as well as the wants, needs, desires and aspirations of any human.
February 8th, 2007 at 10:58 am
Good post MBT, but let’s just also keep in mind that there is a completely innocent victim of an alleged attempted murder here as well.
Ms. Nowak will have to answer for her alleged crimes and be held responsible, as she should.
Perhaps she can blame it on an addiction to Tang, however.
February 8th, 2007 at 12:26 pm
Corey - Absolutely!
I think the media has done a good job of going over the story - and my post is not relieving Mrs. Nowak from responsibility in the crime - she should face the same penalties that we all would.
My point was that most people have a breaking point and in such a known high stress job, especially where image is critical, people should be offered opportunities to decompress. I also wanted to try to make sense out of something that seems to be out of our ability to comprehend…
Thanks for stopping by! Come by more often!
February 8th, 2007 at 2:27 pm
Fantastic and fabulously written and well-stated post, MBT. No way to improve on that.
Of course Nowak isn’t excused. But that really isn’t the point (I mean, making people understand consequences of behavior is of course one point here, but there’s an awful lot more than that going on, sadly).
Innocent victim - yes and maybe not - we don’t know 100% yet, but I agree - right now, it looks that way.
No one - not a single one of us - is immune from having a breaking point. God-willing most of us will never get so close to it that it gets breached.
February 8th, 2007 at 5:15 pm
um … just to play devil’s advocate for a moment …
maybe she’s just bonkers
people like to think our “leaders” are somehow these super intelligent stable mature people.
i propose an alternative hypothesis. maybe she wasn’t driven to the brink … maybe she’s just crazy.
my dad happens to work for nasa. it is actually not one huge pressure cooker. though granted the cosmonaughts have tremendous extra pressures on them doing PR and stuff … but i never met anyone who didn’t like working there. it’s very prestigious to work for nasa and especially since challenger they have made great efforts to take political pressure of the agency.
so in short, don’t discount the possibility she is just crazy …
February 8th, 2007 at 5:28 pm
star trek? eeek
but if you must reference something that
DOESN’T EXIST
aren’t there any women with pointy ears in star trek?
mbt did you have every geeky boy in your high school chasing you?
February 9th, 2007 at 2:28 am
I read somewhere that she was distraught over the Challenger crash so many years ago that took her pals. Still, some people face tragedy admirably, others fall apart.
She obviously WAS bonkers to do this as MBT points out at the end of her piece, so Lisa has a point too. But she wasn’t always bonkers. She is just perhaps a weak person who didn’t handle the normal stress of life like a normal person. And she was a man-izer, apparently trying to seduce her own son in law, and insanely jealous about another woman who was legitimately seeing the man who she was also apparently screwing behind her husband’s back. I think I have those sordid facts right.
Bonkers is right. She went bonkers. She shouldn’t have gone bonkers. She was weak and for me an entirely unsympathetic woman to inflict so much misery on other people who did her no harm.
And that’s all too bad because she was America’s finest as MBT pointed out. She isn’t anymore and it is her fault. I teach my kids there is nothing special about baseball players who they see as 10 foot tall heroes. They are people. Astronauts are people too, some good and some really suck like Lisa Nowak.
This is one of the most thought-provoking pieces I’ve read on RightPundits. Thanks for doing it.
February 9th, 2007 at 7:14 am
Why thank you McCain - that is quite a compliment!
lisab - what is wrong with geeks? Bill Gates is a geek, so is 9/10 of the kazillionaires today. Also, i have heard bloggers accused of being geeks - so welcome to geekdom!
And yes - there are pointy-eared females and strong-willed Klingon females with wrinkled foreheads.
February 9th, 2007 at 1:44 pm
McCain and MBT,
why is it that if a teenager grows up in south central los angelas with little to no parenting, little education and few prospects admidst crime and poverty and they mug an old lady, people want to try them as adults and throw them in jail for years …
but if a relatively well-off, well educated, high ranking woman with a prestigious job and who is showered with praise and accolades her adult life, drives cross country, in diapers with a bb gun and sprays mace at a rival girlfriend, people hesitate to call her crazy nevermind suggest she could just be plain bad …
i say we examine several possible hypotheses and then apply ockham’s razor.
a.) she has been under a lot of stress recently and what she did is totally understandable … naturally anyone under that kind of pressure would wear diapers and drive cross country given those circumstances …
b.) she stopped smoking recently
c.) she has really really bad pms
d.) she’s (move your index finger rapidly over your lips) i.e. she’s bonkers
f.) she’s a bad person
this … “she’s had a hard time” stuff gets my goat. i’ve known people who have lived in abject poverty their entire lives and they don’t go around spraying mace at people … and i’m talking real third world type poverty not usa style poverty …
and finally, though i’ll give her the benefit of the doubt and assume she’s just nuts … i have a sister who is a brilliant statistician, makes a ton of money, and for christmas one year took her kids to see harry potter — that’s it. no other presents. now some say she’s teaching her children to appreciate what they have and to not grow up a “spoiled brat” like their youngest aunt.
but i know better. she’s just a f’n cheap mean cow. sometimes a cigar is just a cigar and sometimes a raging psycho bitch is a raging phsycho bitch
February 9th, 2007 at 2:50 pm
the really apalling thing … apart from my terrible grammar above — is that had she missed the victim’s flight and not been arrested … that night she could have gone to a local bar and hooked up with some random stranger … and a few weeks later we would have read
(since anna nicole is on the news)
“dear playboy,
i never thought these letters were real, and i never thought anything like this would happen to me but … last week i went to a bar and hooked up with an astronaught! she was totally hot, passionate, and really a freak in bed.
she didn’t even wear underwear … she wore diapers!!! she also wore a wig, a trenchcoat and had a bb gun.
talk about the big bang theory … this woman was out of this world …” etc. etc.
take the same exact situation, but change the perp to a man and everyone would be calling for severe penalties … um …
okay wait a minute … what am i saying … this time the double standars is in my favor … forget i mentioned anything
February 9th, 2007 at 4:04 pm
lisab - at least you see the flaws in your reasoning. It is a step in the right direction toward your rehabilitation.
BTW - Occam’s Razor applies to natural phenomenon - I can’t imagine that it applies to love crazed pms astronuat women.
February 9th, 2007 at 6:10 pm
I’m with ya Lisa. She is a bad person who deserves no sympathy. Just like inner city crime kids.
February 9th, 2007 at 11:41 pm
I may have learned most of what I know about Astronauts from watching “I Dream of Jeannie” reruns :), but I don’t think they let just anyone fly those things. It’s not not like they go into Donna’s Truckstop, find someone scarfing down something greasy there, and say: Hey you! Wanna fly a Space Shuttle? They look up with burrito hangin’ outta thier mouth and say “Uh..yeah..I guess so”. Seems like she wasn’t all mental for a long time. I mean, if she was a Navy pilot, and then a test pilot, she probably was tested lots befor NASA to see if she handled stress ok. For that matter, I thought there were folks that monitored our Astronauts for signs of anything odd. Guess not, or maybe they dropped the ball on Nowak. I’d say maybe she was really good at dealing with her stress (at least outwardly) for a long time. Probably a lot longer than most, or she wouldn’t have gotten to the point she did. Maybe it built up, and she added most of it herself with her apparent “love” life shenannigans until the launch of Crackpot 1.
A good example of smart people doing dumb things, huh? How many lives did she affect with her Bozo impersonation, besides the reputation of Astronauts in general and NASA, I mean? The whole thing is pretty sad. Although, on the bright side, I learned that if I ever wanted to make a long trip as fast as possible, wearing diapers would work.
February 10th, 2007 at 11:46 am
Weirdo
February 10th, 2007 at 12:38 pm
greta: ‘m greta van susteran of fox republican news … and i’m here at court where alleged criminal lisa “the schoolteacher” b, is about to plead. as you know lisab allegedly went on a cross country rampage and sprayed mace on another schoolteacher who apparently stole her black whiteboard marker
(which by the way is a serious crime in any school)
(all rise)
judge: now your client lisab is charged with driving cross country in diapers with a bb gun with intent to kidnap and possible murder the victim who mistakenly took her white board marker … how does she plead?
Bitterlaw: not guilty your honor … by reason that she was a little stressed out,
judge: stressed out?
Bitterlaw: yes your honor. she works your honor (gasps from the gallery), and though it’s obvious — just for the record, she is a woman your honor (more gasps from the gallery).
judge: (pounding gavel) quiet! or i’ll clear the court.
i see, mr. Bitterlaw. anything else?
Bitterlaw: yes your honor, i would like to remind the court that the so-called “victim” wantonly and repeatedly took my client’s black whiteboard marker. (muttering from the jury and gasps from the gallary)
also your honor, i have a doctor’s note here that i would like to submit as evidence at this time.
(the bailiff hands the note to the judge who proceeds to read it)
judge: mr Bitterlaw, it says here your client was retaining water … is that true?
Bitterlaw: yes your honor, she was completely bloated at the time, and i am prepared to produce several affidavids that clearly bear witness to the fact that my client was suffering from pms on the day in question.
judge: mr prosecutor, i don’t think you have a case here.
a.) she is a woman and a working woman at that.
b.) she was suffering from pms
c.) she was a little stressed out …
prosecutor: but your honor, what about the victim?
Bitterlaw: objection your honr!!!!!!!!
judge: sustained!!!! and one more word mr. prosecutor and i’ll have you bound over for contempt!
CASE DISMISSED!!!!
(conservatives in the gallary cheer)
greta: well there you have it, justice served. imagine the gall of the clearly democrat prosecutor trying to apply the laws equally in this country … thankfully calmer heads prevailed, and i imagine the voters will be going after this prosecutor in the next election … back to you brit hume
February 10th, 2007 at 12:41 pm
Lisa, I want the movie rights to your script!
February 10th, 2007 at 12:42 pm
IMI, if the astronaut looked more like Barbara Eden, I think I would agree with MBT more.
February 10th, 2007 at 12:49 pm
Uh lisab - I wasn’t aware that this was a Dem vs. GOP thing. Am I missing something? Jill is a D and she agrees with me so there :>p ((you should be used tot his type of arguments from your school kids! )
Good script though!
February 10th, 2007 at 12:59 pm
One change you need to make to the script though - Greta is a flaming liberal! A HUGE D! Her sister ran in the primary for Congress here this year.
I think OJ was pms’ing too - which is how he got off, I’m sure.
February 10th, 2007 at 1:16 pm
“I wasn’t aware that this was a Dem vs. GOP thing”
this is why you guys lost the election … you nambi pambi weak on crime conservatives just can’t get it it though your heads that violent criminals can’t be tolerated …
next you’ll be saying the duke lacrosse boys should be let go
February 10th, 2007 at 1:20 pm
mbt,
i forgot about greta’s sister … but actually i think greta herself and nancy grace for that matter are both tough on crime dems
though i just don’t get why you guys have sympathy for her … she violently attacked someone
and since you brought it up people thought oj was a funny guy … until he butchered two people …
February 10th, 2007 at 1:27 pm
“Jill is a D and she agrees with me so there :>p ”
jill perhaps needs to be reminded that as modern women we are NOT seeking superiority over men, (we’ll always have that), we are simply seeking equality under the law
even when it means we are prosecuted … to do otherwise is to claim diminished responsibility based on our gender; like for example when that blonde schoolteacher basically got no jail time after having sex with a 14 year old boy … that is a travesty
that she was a woman should not make any difference in the eyes of the law
August 29th, 2007 at 3:23 am
World largest dating portal…
…